Skip to article

For Schools

How to Measure a School Peer Mentoring Program

A measurement framework for participation, relationship quality, student feedback, school connectedness, and responsible interpretation.

By Tagapag Team3 min read

A school may be able to count registered mentors and mentees, but participation statistics alone cannot establish that students feel more connected or supported. A useful evaluation plan measures both program operations and the experiences of the people involved.

Start with a small set of measures the school can collect responsibly and consistently. Protect students’ privacy, keep optional feedback voluntary where appropriate, and distinguish observations from evidence of impact.

Operational measures: is the program happening?

Track the number of eligible participants, introductions completed, ongoing matches, check-ins, and requests for staff help. Look for drop-off and uneven access, not just totals.

  • Participation: How many students actually started a mentoring relationship?
  • Continuity: Are matches still meeting or checking in after the first few weeks?
  • Support: How quickly are unmatched students or concerns followed up?

Experience measures: is the relationship useful?

Ask short, age-appropriate questions about whether mentees know whom to contact, feel comfortable asking questions, and perceive their mentor as reliable. Ask mentors whether expectations are clear and staff support is sufficient.

Offer an option to say a match is not helpful without blaming either student. Open-ended feedback often identifies practical adjustments that totals miss.

Outcomes: be careful about cause and effect

A pre- and post-program survey may reveal changes in reported confidence or school connectedness, but it cannot by itself prove the program caused those changes. School events, maturation, self-selection, and other supports may also influence results.

If a school wants stronger evidence, its evaluation lead can consider an appropriate comparison design and review requirements. Never publish identifiable student narratives or individual survey responses without proper permission.

A practical reporting rhythm

Use a brief launch baseline, a midpoint operational review, and an end-of-pilot summary. Include what went well, where the program struggled, how many students responded, and what changes will be made.

MENTOR’s program-quality and evaluation guidance is a useful reference when selecting measures. Treat any Tagapag usage dashboards as operational indicators, not independent evidence of well-being or academic improvement.

Sources & further reading

These references inform the discussion. Research on school connectedness or other mentoring programs is not evidence that Tagapag has produced the same outcomes.

Published
View all resources