Skip to article

Research & Evidence

What Does the Evidence Say About Peer Mentoring in High Schools?

A balanced look at peer mentoring evidence, including results from randomized studies and the limits of generalizing to new school programs.

By Tagapag Team3 min read

Peer mentoring can take many forms: older students guiding freshmen, groups led by trained student leaders, and ongoing one-to-one relationships. These programs are not interchangeable, so claims about effectiveness need to specify what was studied and how success was measured.

A useful way to read the evidence is to distinguish promising individual findings from results that are consistent across studies.

A randomized study found mixed results

A 2023 study of a cross-age peer mentoring program during the middle-to-high-school transition followed 1,351 ninth-grade students. The study did not find an effect on its two confirmatory outcomes—ninth-grade attendance and credit accrual—under its main intent-to-treat analysis.

Exploratory analyses suggested modest possible benefits for some measures such as school attachment, discipline, and expectations for degree attainment. Because exploratory findings are not the same as confirmatory results, they should be presented cautiously.

Other programs have produced positive findings in specific settings

An earlier randomized evaluation of a peer-led high school transition program found higher four-year graduation rates for male participants in one low-income school context. That is encouraging evidence for the particular program and population studied.

It would be inaccurate to assume the same graduation effect will occur in a different district, with another curriculum, or through a digital mentorship platform.

Quality of implementation matters

MENTOR’s Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring outlines considerations including program design, screening, preparation, matching, ongoing support, and evaluation. The practical lesson is that relationships need a supporting program structure—not simply an initial introduction.

Schools should inspect how mentors are trained, which students can participate, what support is available, and how concerns are handled before treating a program as ready.

Where this leaves a new school program

Peer mentoring is a credible approach to explore, not a guaranteed outcome. Schools can begin with a clear purpose, an approved program, and modest measures of participation and perceived usefulness; stronger claims about effects require stronger evaluation.

Tagapag is a tool for organizing some of those relationships and activities. It should not be represented as having produced the effects reported in studies of other programs.

Sources & further reading

These references inform the discussion. Research on school connectedness or other mentoring programs is not evidence that Tagapag has produced the same outcomes.

Published
View all resources